Airbnb

With over 150 millions users and 2 million people checking into one of its properties every night, this success story is facing conformity challenges.

Airbnb

With over 150 millions users and 2 million people checking into one of its properties every night, this success story is facing conformity challenges.

Airbnb

With over 150 millions users and 2 million people checking into one of its properties every night, this success story is facing conformity challenges.

Airbnb

With over 150 millions users and 2 million people checking into one of its properties every night, this success story is facing conformity challenges.

Airbnb

With over 150 millions users and 2 million people checking into one of its properties every night, this success story is facing conformity challenges.

Airbnb

With over 150 millions users and 2 million people checking into one of its properties every night, this success story is facing conformity challenges.

MY ROLE

UX/UI Designer

TOOLS

Figma, Notion

TEAM

3 Designers

DATE

2022

SCOPE

2 weeks

Overview

CONTEXT

Company Background

Company Background

Airbnb has completely shifted the hospitality industry over the last decade and strongly participated to the recent travel revolution.


Founded in 2008 by Brian Chesky and Nathan Blecharczyk, the preferred one-night booking platform operates as a peer to peer marketplace for short-term vacation rentals and offers a wide range of options worldwide among its 5.6 million active listings.

Lydia

Lydia is a leading mobile financial services with a loyal community of free users around the peer to peer payment.

Lydia

Lydia is a leading mobile financial services with a loyal community of free users around the peer to peer payment.

Lydia

Lydia is a leading mobile financial services with a loyal community of free users around the peer to peer payment.

CHALLENGE

CHALLENGE

CHALLENGE

How can we ensure travelers the accuracy and conformity of the accommodation listings?
How can we ensure travelers the accuracy and conformity of the accommodation listings?
How can we ensure travelers the accuracy and conformity of the accommodation listings?
How can we ensure travelers the accuracy and conformity of the accommodation listings?

WHY ?

Complaints on the app store

We know there is a conformity issue by reading many bad reviews about this matter on the app store.

KEY SUCCESS CRITERIA

KEY SUCCESS CRITERIA

KEY SUCCESS CRITERIA

Conformity rating

Increase in the average rating for conformity


Positive feedback

Drop of negative reviews related to thoses issues

Customer satisfaction

Fewer refund request & complaints


Loyalty boost

Increase in retention to strengthen loyalty

Conformity rating

Conformity
rating

Increase in the average rating for conformity


Positive feedback

Positive
feedback

Drop of negative reviews related to thoses issues

Customer satisfaction

Customer
satisfaction

Fewer refund request & complaints


Loyalty boost

Loyalty
boost

Increase in retention to strengthen loyalty

Discover

BENCHMARKS

BENCHMARK

Competitive analysis

We performed a competitive analysis to understand how leading businesses address similar challenges. By examining around 10 products, we identified key strategies to minimize non-conformity risks.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Pictures Dates : Ensures up-to-date visual content.

Virtual Tours : Offers an immersive experience for users.

Presentation Tags : Provides a concise summary of oferings.

Posting Guidance : Clear instructions to help users create effective listings.

Comment Filters : Enhances comment navigation and relevance.

Keyword Search in Comments : Enables quick information retrieval in comments

Experience Badges : Highlights experienced and exceptional hosts and travelers.

Define

Define

UNDERSTAND

CONFORMITY

UNDERSTAND

CONFORMITY

Conformity Assessment

Before digging further into this project, we needed to get a detailed understanding of conformity assessment.


This step was crucial to fully comprehend the broad scope of the problem. We made sure to consider all the relevant implications and actors concerned.

What do we understand exactly by conformity and listing accuracy ?

What do we understand exactly by conformity and listing accuracy ?

What do we understand exactly by conformity and listing accuracy ?

1

Subjective

interpretation

2

Transparency

& honesty

3

Responsibility Monitoring

4

Importance

of the community

STAY
PHASES

Actions to maximise compliance

Ensuring compliance of lodging listings on Airbnb involves addressing each phase of the stay with targeted actions. Focusing on these steps before, during, and after the stay enhances user satisfaction and trust.


Integrating these measures at every stage is essential for achieving optimal compliance, meeting travelers' expectations, and providing a high-quality, reliable lodging experience.

Check content accuracy

and clarify listing

Check Before

Check Before

Report mismatch

or malfunction

Report During

Report During

Share after

Share your experience

with the community

Share your experience

with the community

Deliver

PROTOYPE V1

Task prioritisation

To enhance the application within a short timeframe, it was imperative to plan ahead and prioritise our tasks.


Our main solution was based on the prioritisation of listing content to highlight certain information and foster a climate of trust and transparency. We implemented micro features helping travelers to assess listing accuracy and personalise their research

Pictures & virtual tour

Key element of the listing

Video icon on the preview indicating a virtual tour

2021

Publication date on each picture of the listing

Publication date

The date on pictures is a way to increase vigilance and provides a hint of the risk to face an unreasonable wear and tear.

Accomodation virtual tour

We included a video to help travelers project themselves and have a clear idea of the layout of the accomodation.

Play button suggesting a virtual tour video is available

Rainbow circle around the preiview picture

Comments & Criterion

Target those matching your priorities

Circular Gauges

Cleanliness rating

Dot navigation

Search comments

Dot navigation

Compliance Rating

Conformity is refined as the
number of comments increases.

Travelers' overall impression is based on the nature of comments left by previous travelers. Therefore, we personalized travelers' search by adding new features in the comments section

Define

Define

UNDERSTAND CONFORMITY

Conformity Assessment

Before digging further into this project, we needed to get a detailed understanding of conformity assessment.


This step was crucial to fully comprehend the broad scope of the problem. We made sure to consider all the relevant implications and actors concerned.

What do we understand exactly by conformity and listing accuracy ?

1

Subjective

interpretation

2

Transparency

& honesty

3

Responsibility Monitoring

4

Importance

of the community

STAY
PHASES

Actions to maximise compliance

Ensuring compliance of lodging listings on Airbnb involves addressing each phase of the stay with targeted actions. Focusing on these steps before, during, and after the stay enhances user satisfaction and trust.


Integrating these measures at every stage is essential for achieving optimal compliance, meeting travelers' expectations, and providing a high-quality, reliable lodging experience.

Check content accuracy

and clarify listing

Check Before

Report mismatch

or malfunction

Report During

Share after

Share your experience

with the community

Develop

Define

IDEATION

EXERCICES

IDEATION

EXERCICES

Mindmap & Crazy 8S

Our mind map has been instrumental in highlighting crucial aspects for ensuring conformity and understanding the distinct roles each actor plays.


Purpose :

  • Ensure all aspects of conformity are identified and considered.

  • Group associated ideas and create hierarchies.

  • Focus on the most promising objectives.


Our mind map has been instrumental in highlighting crucial aspects for ensuring conformity and understanding the distinct roles each actor plays.


Purpose :

  • Ensure all aspects of conformity are identified and considered.

  • Group associated ideas and create hierarchies.

  • Focus on the most promising objectives.


Our mind map has been instrumental in highlighting crucial aspects for ensuring conformity and understanding the distinct roles each actor plays.


Purpose :

  • Ensure all aspects of conformity are identified and considered.

  • Group associated ideas and create hierarchies.

  • Focus on the most promising objectives.


Our mind map has been instrumental in highlighting crucial aspects for ensuring conformity and understanding the distinct roles each actor plays.


Purpose :

  • Ensure all aspects of conformity are identified and considered.

  • Group associated ideas and create hierarchies.

  • Focus on the most promising objectives.


KEY FACTORS & STAKEHOLDERS

Accuracy

Accurate, up-to-date information prevents mismatches and ensures satisfaction. Clear expectations & support help avoid issues with listings.

Fraud

Detecting and preventing fraudulent activities is critical. Airbnb must monitor and address fraudulent behavior promptly to maintain trust and safety.

Subjectivity

Detecting and preventing fraudulent activities is critical. Airbnb must monitor and address fraudulent behavior promptly to maintain trust and safety.

Community

Trust, feedback, and traveler participation are vital. Transparency and shared experiences build a trustworthy community.

Host

Honesty, regular updates, active involvement, and responsiveness are essential. Clear communication ensures reliability and reassures travelers.

Airbnb

Responsibility, safety, rapid problem identification and support are key. Assistance is crucial for a secure user experience, but procedures remain limited

KEY FACTORS & STAKEHOLDERS

Accuracy

Accurate, up-to-date information prevents mismatches and ensures satisfaction. Clear expectations & support help avoid issues with listings.

Fraud

Detecting and preventing fraudulent activities is critical. Airbnb must monitor and address fraudulent behavior promptly to maintain trust and safety.

Subjectivity

Detecting and preventing fraudulent activities is critical. Airbnb must monitor and address fraudulent behavior promptly to maintain trust and safety.

Community

Trust, feedback, and traveler participation are vital. Transparency and shared experiences build a trustworthy community.

Host

Honesty, regular updates, active involvement, and responsiveness are essential. Clear communication ensures reliability and reassures travelers.

Airbnb

Responsibility, safety, rapid problem identification and support are key. Assistance is crucial for a secure user experience, but procedures remain limited

SCENARIO

EXPLORATION

Storyboards

Those storyboards helped us to visualise our concepts from both point of views : host and travelers.

It was also an effective way to project ourself into the flow we wanted to create and generate key concept for our solutions .

SCENARIO
EXPLORATION

1

2

3

4

5

6

Keywords search in the comments

Filter comments by criteria

Publication date ( pictures)

Ambassador concept ( superhost version traveler)

Notifcation to update the listing

Profile : see previous comments left by travellers

(discourage overly critical individual)

Keywords search in the comments

Filter comments by criteria

Publication date ( pictures)

Ambassador concept ( superhost version traveler)

Notifcation to update the listing

Profile : see previous comments left by travellers

(discourage overly critical individual)

Keywords search in the comments

Filter comments by criteria

Publication date ( pictures)

Ambassador concept ( superhost vs traveler)

Notifcation to update the listing

Profile : see previous comments left by travellers

(discourage overly critical individual)

Keywords search in the comments

Filter comments by criteria

Publication date ( pictures)

Ambassador concept ( superhost version traveler)

Notifcation to update the listing

Profile : see previous comments left by travellers

(discourage overly critical individual)

INFORMATION

ARCHITECTURE

INFORMATION ARCHITECTURE

INFORMATION

ARCHITECTURE

Breakdown of the listing page

We analyzed the listing page views to understand how members access the listings and which information they value most, based on comments. This helped us identify the main causes of non-conformity :

Recurring complaints :

  • Missing / Broken amenities

  • Accomodations layout

  • Cleanliness

Common complaints :

  • Inacurrate listing

  • Misleading location

  • Scams

Lack of clear process

During this analysis we also realised airbnb didn't have a clear process regarding conformity issue. If there is a mismatch or a fraud, travelers can contact customers service, but there isn't a dedicated feature to make it a priority.


When a problem emerges, travelers require airbnb to adress it with reactivity, but the lack of clear process makes it more delicate to handle.


Deliver

PROTOYPE V1

PROTOYPE V1

Task prioritisation

To enhance the application within a short timeframe, it was imperative to plan ahead and prioritise our tasks.


Our main solution was based on the prioritisation of listing content to highlight certain information and foster a climate of trust and transparency. We implemented micro features helping travelers to assess listing accuracy and personalise their research

Pictures & virtual tour

Key element of the listing

Pictures & virtual tour

Key element of the listing

Video icon on the preview indicating a virtual tour

2021

Publication date on each picture of the listing

Publication date

Publication date

The date on pictures is a way to increase vigilance and provides a hint of the risk to face an unreasonable wear and tear.

The date on pictures is a way to increase vigilance and provides a hint of the risk to face an unreasonable wear and tear.

Accomodation virtual tour

Accomodation virtual tour

We included a video to help travelers project themselves and

have a clear idea of the layout of the accomodation.

We included a video to help travelers project themselves and

have a clear idea of the layout of the accomodation.

Play button suggesting a virtual tour video is available

Rainbow circle around the preiview picture

KEY METRICS TO MONITOR

Average Conformity Rating

Are the new entry points effectively guiding users to payment limit information and encouraging interaction with the limit pages ?

Negative Review Rate

Tracks the decrease in negative reviews to assess the effectiveness of user experience enhancements.

User Retention Rate

Are we seeing a significant drop in support tickets related to freemium limits ?

Refund & Compaint Rate

What is the conversion rate of users upgrading to premium plans? The target conversion rate should ideally be between 5% to 10%.

Thanks for visiting

Comments & Criterion

Target those matching your priorities

Circular Gauges

Cleanliness rating

Dot navigation

Search comments

Dot navigation

Compliance Rating

Dot navigation

Compliance Rating

Conformity is refined as the
number of comments increases.

Conformity is refined as the
number of comments increases.

Travelers' overall impression is based on the nature of comments left by previous travelers. Therefore, we personalized travelers' search by adding new features in the comments section

Travelers' overall impression is based on the nature of comments left by previous travelers. Therefore, we personalized travelers' search by adding new features in the comments section

#FF5A5F

#000000

#FF385C

#EAEAEA

#008489

#FFFFFF

#484848

Bold

Medium

Light

ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ

abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz

0123456789

!@#$%*&^()

ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ

abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz

0123456789

!@#$%*&^()

ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ

abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz

0123456789

!@#$%*&^()

Airbnb Cereal App

Color system

Icons

Aa

Aa

Buttons

Primary/Default

Primary/Pressed

Primary/Pressed

Primary/Default

Secondary / pressed

Secondary / default

Explorer

Favoris

Voyages

Messages

Profil

UI Design Kit

USABILITY

TESTING

Test context & objectives

We conducted usability tests with 5 participants. The goal was to test our solution concept, understand participants habits when booking an accomodation and detect pain points in our prototype.

1

Identify the primary elements travelers consider

when evaluating the accuracy of a listing

2

Evaluate the importance given to conformity

when booking accommodation

3

Determine if the rating criterias are decisive when choosing an acocmodation

USABILITY

TESTING

Test context & objectives

We conducted usability tests with 5 participants. The goal was to test our solution concept, understand participants habits when booking an accomodation and detect pain points in our prototype.

1

Identify the primary elements travelers consider when

evaluating the accuracy of a listing

Identify the primary elements travelers consider

when evaluating the accuracy of a listing

2

Evaluate the importance given to conformity when booking

accommodation

Evaluate the importance given to conformity when booking accommodation

Evaluate the importance given to conformity when

booking accommodation

3

Determine if the rating criterias are decisive when choosing an

acocmodation

Determine if the rating criterias are decisive when choosing an acocmodation

Determine if the rating criterias are decisive when

choosing an acocmodation

Seeing a date on the photos was particularly appreciated by users

The dated photos & virtual tour were unanousmly considered reassuring.

5/5

participants

Finding #1

Quick responses, detailed profiles increase trust & likelihood of booking

The host's profile & responsiveness are decisive when booking an accommodation.

4/5

participants

Finding #2

It would be so nice to have a virtual visit to see the corners and space before you arrive.

Camille, 26 yo

Regular user

It would be so nice to have a virtual visit to see the corners and space before you arrive.

Camille, 26 yo

Regular user

Users often miss the rating classification but find it helpful

3/5

participants

Finding #3

The classification of comments by rating criteria is mostly understood but not always seen.

Users check specific amenities; consider

them crucial for booking

Amenities are a decisive factor when it comes to the perceived conformity of an accommodation listing.

3/5

participants

Finding #4

Deliver

PROTOYPE V1

Task prioritisation

To enhance the application within a short timeframe, it was imperative to plan ahead and prioritise our tasks.


Our main solution was based on the prioritisation of listing content to highlight certain information and foster a climate of trust and transparency. We implemented micro features helping travelers to assess listing accuracy and personalise their research

Pictures & virtual tour

Key element of the listing

Video icon on the preview indicating a virtual tour

2021

Publication date on each picture of the listing

Publication date

The date on pictures is a way to increase vigilance and provides a hint of the risk to face an unreasonable wear and tear.

Accomodation virtual tour

We included a video to help travelers project themselves and

have a clear idea of the layout of the accomodation.

Play button suggesting a virtual tour video is available

Rainbow circle around the preiview picture

Comments & Criterion

Target those matching your priorities

Circular Gauges

Cleanliness rating

Dot navigation

Search comments

Dot navigation

Compliance Rating

Conformity is refined as the
number of comments increases.

Travelers' overall impression is based on the nature of comments left by previous travelers. Therefore, we personalized travelers' search by adding new features in the comments section

#FF5A5F

#000000

#FF385C

#EAEAEA

#008489

#FFFFFF

#484848

Bold

Medium

Light

ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ

abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz

0123456789

!@#$%*&^()

ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ

abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz

0123456789

!@#$%*&^()

ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ

abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz

0123456789

!@#$%*&^()

Airbnb Cereal App

Color system

Icons

Aa

Aa

Buttons

Primary/Default

Primary/Pressed

Primary/Pressed

Primary/Default

Secondary / pressed

Secondary / default

Explorer

Favoris

Voyages

Messages

Profil

UI Design Kit

Iteration

Iteration

Iteration

FINAL SOLUTION - V2

Value more host’s profile on the listing page

Value more host’s profile on the listing page

Value more host’s profile on

the listing page

We underestimated the importance of the host's profile: users often looked for it first for reassurance on responsiveness and commitment.

Many struggled to find it, so we moved the host's profile to the top of the listing, just below the picture, and added multiple entry points.

This improvement helps users quickly find the info they need to feel confident in their choice.

We underestimated the importance of the host's profile: users often looked for it first for reassurance on responsiveness and commitment.

Many struggled to find it, so we moved the host's profile to the top of the listing, just below the picture, and added multiple entry points.

This improvement helps users quickly find the info they need to feel confident in their choice.

Add filters in the comments search bar

Add filters in the comments search bar

Each rating criteria is still clickable but we also included complimentary search criterias filters in the comments section : global rating, criteria rating, publication date, frequently mentioned keywords

As we noticed the classification of comments by rating criteria was not always seen during the test, we added multiples filters criterias in the comments search bar.

Report an issue with amenities in the post trip survey

Report an issue with amenities in the post trip survey

During the usability test, most participants informed us they were checking in details amenities, even on pictures to avoid bad surprises when they’ll arrive.

We therefore decided to include an easy way to report an issue with an appliance.

Next traveler would be informed before booking as the incident will be displayed on the accomodation listing until the issue has been solved,

Final Prototype

KEY METRICS TO MONITOR

Average Conformity Rating

Are the new entry points effectively guiding users to payment limit information and encouraging interaction with the limit pages ?

Negative Review Rate

Tracks the decrease in negative reviews to assess the effectiveness of user experience enhancements.

User Retention Rate

Are we seeing a significant drop in support tickets related to freemium limits ?

Refund & Compaint Rate

What is the conversion rate of users upgrading to premium plans? The target conversion rate should ideally be between 5% to 10%.

Average Conformity Rating

Are the new entry points effectively guiding users to payment limit information and encouraging interaction with the limit pages?

Negative Review Rate

Tracks the decrease in negative reviews to assess the effectiveness of user experience enhancements.

User Retention Rate

Are we seeing a significant drop in support tickets related to freemium limits ?

Refund & Compaint Rate

What is the conversion rate of users upgrading to premium plans? The target conversion rate should ideally be between 5% to 10%.

Thanks for visiting

THANKS FOR VISITING

I would love to help bring your ideas to life

Feel free to reach out !

Melody Dos Santos Borges

Let's shape impactful designs together & create valuable experiences for your users.

2024 Melody Dos Santos Borges. All Rights Reserved.

THANKS FOR VISITING

I would love to help bring your ideas to life

Feel free to reach out !

Melody Dos Santos Borges

Let's shape impactful designs together & create valuable experiences for your users.

2024 Melody Dos Santos Borges. All Rights Reserved.

THANKS FOR VISITING

I would love to help bring your ideas to life, feel free to reach out !

Melody Dos Santos Borges

Let's shape impactful designs together & create valuable experiences for your users.

2024 Melody Dos Santos Borges. All Rights Reserved.

THANKS FOR VISITING

I would love to help bring your ideas to life

Feel free to reach out !

Melody Dos Santos Borges

Let's shape impactful designs together & create valuable experiences for your users.

2024 Melody Dos Santos Borges. All Rights Reserved.